Security & privacy tools / Compare
Mailinator vs SimpleLogin
Both do 1 of the same security & privacy tools task. Below is what each says about its own limits and pricing, and how each ranks on signals we can measure or quote.
Disclosure: agathox makes some of the tools listed here. They are labelled and scored by the same method as every other tool.
A
Mailinator
Mailinator gives QA teams and developers inboxes for email receipt testing, OTP and 2FA checks, password resets, and SMS workflows, via the UI or API.
Signals score: 4.0 / 5 · not a hands-on test
Visit www.mailinator.comB
SimpleLogin
With email aliases , you can be anonymous online and protect your inbox against spams and phishing.
Signals score: 4.2 / 5 · not a hands-on test
Visit simplelogin.ioPricing, limits and privacy
- Free tier
- A: Free Public plan at $0 per month: unlimited public inboxes, temporary storage (no amount given), SMS testing, API access, webhooks, routing rules, email attachments. Other limits not stated.
- B: Free plan at $0: 10 aliases and 1 mailbox, unlimited bandwidth, reply from alias, browser extensions and mobile apps.
- Paid plan
- A: Business $79 per month billed yearly; Business Plus $159 per month billed yearly; Enterprise from $699 (custom pricing). Verified Pro listed at $0 with verification. Annual plans include a 20% discount. Month-to-month pricing and price by country not stated.
- B: Premium is $36 per year or $4 billed monthly: unlimited aliases, custom domains and mailboxes, 5 subdomains, 50 directories/usernames, catch-all, PGP. No other paid plan listed.
- Signup
- A: The pricing page lists no sign-up required for the Public plan.
- B: Creating an account requires an email address.
- Watermark
- A: Not applicable.
- B: Not stated.
- Where files go
- A: Privacy policy says emails sent to the public system are readable by anyone and in the public domain. Data may be stored and processed in the United States, where its servers and central database are. Retention period for inbox emails is not stated.
- B: Policy says it does not store your emails; messages are deleted once delivered, undeliverable ones kept 7 days. Servers by Proton and UpCloud in Germany, Switzerland, the Netherlands and France. Account deletion purges data within 30 days.
From each tool's own pages, checked 2026-11-01. Prices and limits change; check the tool before you rely on them. Sources are listed on each tool's page.
Compare on a task
Neither tool has been hands-on tested on these tasks yet, and we do not guess. Open a task to see both ranked with every other tool.
More
- Alternatives to Mailinator
- Alternatives to SimpleLogin
- All security & privacy tools, ranked
- How we rank
Know a tool that should be here? Submit it, or write to hello@agathox.com.